Saying My Prayers?

One Man's Web > Mudmap Theology >
The New Church > Saying My Prayers?
 
How I pray now?

See here for full text  There is often a perception that to pray is to ask God for something. This theologically primitive view says I can ask God to interrupt the flow of the universe on my behalf. This idea founders upon the fact that God is apparently quite arbitrary in the answering of prayers, and is a monster who allows indefensible suffering simply because you or I did not say the right words.

Saying prayers depends on the idea that prayer is communion with God in some sense.  That is; there really is a God there who is listening.  When we pray, God hears and in some sense, answers us.  So we could say that the purpose and power of prayer is not in the fact that some god can be persuaded to do things for us.  The purpose and power of prayer is in the fact that we are in relationship with the Divine.  We are being listened to and cared about. 

At first sight this is much more sophisticated, and reasonable, than the primitive idea of asking God to do things. As we see so often in the psalms it also allows one to rail at God for the iniquities and unfairness of the world. However, the notion that God is there to listen in a way analogous to a human being also has problems.  There are problems with what we are implying about the nature of God, and there are problems with believability.

The prayers of Praise in Sunday worship raise issues about the nature of God.  Prayers of praise were originally based in the notion of flattery of the ruler. "Keep the Lord or the King happy and tell him how good he is and he will be kind to us and grant us what we want." We can see the truth of this from the way people's prayers of intercession and petition often spend so much time telling God how good and great he is. If God is God, why does God need to be told how good God is?  If God is God, why does God need to be flattered. If God truly loved the world with compassion, would God need all this?  Is not this kind of obsequious behaviour really an insult to a truly Godly god?

My background was strongly of the opinion that prayer is a verbal affair. You pray with words. It was also a background driven by guilt. We were expected to feel guilty for not praying and since prayer was a largely sterile affair we usually felt guilty about it.

Prayer was sterile because of the emphasis on asking for things. If we are really honest most of what we ask for in prayer does not happen. We can do all sorts of rationalisation about not asking "in His will" and that's why there was no answer, or we can fudge things by doing lots of praying for things which are going to happen anyway and call that answered prayer... but the fact is, that kind of prayer mostly doesn't work.

Prayer was also sterile because the Prayers of Praise and Thanksgiving that were modeled for us, and therefore taught to us, in Sunday church were full of lofty theological phrases outside of our experience. Who really gave a stuff about prayers like
  All praise to You, O Blessed Holy Trinity?... 
Not the farmers who were never led in prayers of thanks for the smell of warm diesel and freshly turned earth on a cold night as the tractor ticked and cooled. And not the farmers who reveled in sweat and dust as the clean grain poured into the bulk bin. We never thanked God for the joy of lumping 10.000 bags into a perfect pile.

And of course it was not prayer unless you said it. I once had to shift seven or eight pallets of bricks to the back of a house. No room for a truck, and low walls stopping a barrow.  The builder gave me two days.  I determined to do it in one, running back to the pallets empty, striding down with five bricks on one arm and three on the other. I wore out a pair of heavy welder's gloves, taping up the fingers as I went.  And sang and rejoiced in the joy of being alive and being able to work. I did it in less than a day... and it never occurred to me then that it was praise of life and being, or a prayer.

I grew into manhood with an unreal and narrow view of prayer. It required me to relate to God in a way I would never relate to anyone else.  So it was unbelievable.  

No wonder that we a
sk if when we pray, are we doing anything other than talking to ourselves. Or if there is a Divine Reality which even hears us, let alone in some sense answers. The whole idea of prayer we have received is often foolish, and a busy prayer life on the model I described in my growing up either says a lot about incredible patience and faithfulness, but probably more about naiveté and perhaps, real-life immaturity.

If we also have come to a position where God does not fit the old models of the "personal father in heaven" or KINGAFAP etc then of course the kind of prayer above, already stretching credibility due to its lack of congruence with our experience, simply fails totally, and we cease to pray. (Hence once of my colleagues, a wonderful pastor, and deeply spiritual, says she no longer prays....)  And indeed, if I define prayer in the old way, then I do not pray either.

But I do pray.  I pray according to the God I know and the person I am.  My prayer is about being with God. And sometimes I still talk to God... but in another way.

This praying seems to be of three kinds.  

There is the prayer of despair or desperation. I quote here Rev Judith Meyer, who expresses this better than I am able.

I don't pray often. 
But when I do, 
it's because I'm desperate.  
I want to tell you about this, 
because sometimes these prayers, 
desperate though they may have been, 
have changed my life. 
Not because they were answered  
in any obvious way. 
Not because the universe offered me any signs 
to confirm that I was going in the right direction. 
Not because of anything outside myself, actually – 
but because of something inside, 
something that allowed me to open up, 
or to change, 
or to move on 
in ways I desperately needed to do.

Judith captures here something of how the depths of our pain or desperation seem to resonate.  What that resonation is I am not sure. Judith says, "Whatever this glimmer of hope and transcendence might be, I was willing to call it God...." 

"Why I Pray"

A sermon by the Rev. Judith E. Meyer
Unitarian Universalist Community Church
Santa Monica, California
November 5, 2000

  
 
  
 
Religious liberals have sought diligently for years 
 
        to find fresh and relevant definitions of prayer. 
 
Bishop John Shelby Spong makes a passionate appeal in his book 
 
        for prayer as the exercise of an authentic life. 
 
"Prayer is what I am doing," he writes, 
 
        "when I live wastefully,  
 
                passionately, and wondrously  
 
                        and invite others to do so with me 
 
                                or even because of me." 
 More practical, perhaps, is the definition we find in our covenant: 
         "Love is the doctrine of this church. 
                 The quest of truth is its sacrament, 
                         and service is its prayer." 
 This perspective is consistent with the Unitarian Universalist emphasis  
         on deeds, not creeds, 
                 as the standard of the good life. 
 We are at our best when we are acting on our principles. 
 The liberal religious understanding of prayer  
         as authentic living or service to others 
                 is an honest attempt to recast traditional religious forms 
                         in the terms of contemporary experience. 
 We do not offer prayers  
         "by storming the gates of heaven," 
                 nor do we imagine our God as residing there. 
 For Bishop Spong, 
         prayer is the here and now experience of coming fully alive. 
 "There is only the call to be open to the depths of life,"  
        he writes, 
                "and to live in such a way as to reveal those depths." 
Bishop Spong writes, 
        "I do not believe that there is a being, 
                 a supernatural deity, 
                         standing over against my world 
                                 who seeks through some invasive process  
                                         to imprint the divine will on the life of my world. 
 The deity I worship," he adds, 
         "is rather part of who I am individually and corporately... 
                 God is the presence in whom my being comes alive." 
 I do not believe in a supernatural deity either. 
 I’m not pinning my hopes on the "everlasting arms" 
         that may or may not be waiting to catch me when I fall. 
 But like Bishop Spong, I do have a sense of God, 
         not the God of theism or the bible, 
                 but a sense of something holy, 
                         which I still seek, however tentatively,  
                                 to be part of my life. 
 And prayer is my appeal to that God  
         or that "something holy" 
               to enter my life and even to change it. 
 This is the culmination,  
         if you can call it that, 
                 of the years I have spent  
                         contemplating, rejecting and revising my image of God. 
 As those of you who have children are frequently reminded, 
         this thinking starts early in all of us. 
 When I was very young,  
         I had many fervent religious interests 
                 and tried everything from devotional rituals 
                         to giving up listening to my transistor radio for Lent, 
                                 as a way of seeking God. 
 My parents tolerated my preoccupations 
         with good humor and little comprehension. 
 I asked my father if he believed in God. 
 "I worship Apollo," he told me, 
         and then directed me to read all of Bulfinch's Mythology. 
 They were good Unitarian Universalist parents, 
         but they tried too hard to intellectualize religion 
                 and left me looking on my own  
                         for spiritual experiences. 
 They think that is why I became a minister. 
   My childhood image of God as the object of devotion 
         soon gave way to God as an intellectual exercise 
                 when I studied philosophy in college. 
 There is nothing quite as effective for losing faith in God 
         as studying proofs of His existence! 
 Once I made it to Hegel and then on to Marx,  
         Heidegger and the existentialists, 
                 I never looked back. 
 I became convinced that the human enterprise was tragic, 
         that the only authentic state was anxiety, 
                   and we could save ourselves 
 
                        only by facing up to this bleak reality. 
 
After a while, I cheered up, 
 
        and wondered whether God might have something to do 
 
                with life not always being tragic 
 
                        and occasionally offering some relief instead of dread. 
 
Whatever this glimmer of hope and transcendence might be,  
 
        I was willing to call it God, 
 
                and today I still do. 
 
It's just a glimmer, 
 
        but the light stays on. 
 
  
 
My sense of God has changed throughout my life, 
 
        as I imagine it has for you, 
 
                and yet something I’ve noticed 
 
                        is that my use of prayer has hardly changed at all. 
 
I admire the liberal religious view of prayer  
 
        as service, 
 
                or social action, 
 
                        or celebration, 
 
                                or any of the ways in which  
 
                                        we are at our best, 
 
                                                                but that's not how I pray. 
 
I don't pray often. 
 
But when I do, 
 
        it's because I'm desperate. 
 
  
 
I want to tell you about this, 
 
        because sometimes these prayers, 
 
                desperate though they may have been, 
 
                        have changed my life. 
 
Not because they were answered  
 
        in any obvious way. 
 
Not because the universe offered me any signs 
 
        to confirm that I was going in the right direction. 
 
Not because of anything outside myself, actually – 
 
        but because of something inside, 
 
                something that allowed me to open up, 
 
                        or to change, 
 
                                or to move on 
 
                                        in ways I desperately needed to do. 
 
  
 
I have prayed for sleep. 
 
I have prayed for forgiveness. 
 
I have prayed when I've had it with my perfectionism 
 
        and need help with acceptance. 
 
I have prayed for healing. 
 
I have prayed for people I know who are suffering. 
 
I have prayed by hospital bedsides  
 
when there is nothing left to say. 
 
And I have prayed  
 
        when I feel cut off from the spirit of life, 
 
                when I feel trapped, 
 
                        no longer in touch with my own true self. 
 
  
 
Our story for the children this morning 
 
        was a mystical narrative in which the Maasai Man 
 
                sings to the spirits of the animals caged in the zoo. 
 
They get a glimmering of something  
 
        that reminds them of who they really are, 
 
                and they don't feel sad and trapped anymore. 
 
When they remember their own true selves, 
 
        they feel free. 
 
  
 
Prayer is like the song of the Maasai man.       
 
It can rekindle the awareness of who we really are, 
 
        and remind us of the spirit within.  
 
We can turn to it when we feel trapped too, 
 
        held back by our own limitations and weaknesses, 
 
                or frustrated by the constraints our lives have imposed on us, 
 
                        or when we have nowhere else to turn. 
 
  
 
The best advice anyone ever gave me about prayer was this: 
 
        just ask for what you want. 
 
Just ask:  
 
        not because you will receive, 
 
                but because there is hope and healing 
 
                        in naming what you want. 
 
There is hope and healing in the truth, 
 
        whatever the outcome you seek. 
 
  
 
Mary Oliver writes, 
 
        "[And] if your spirit carries within it 
 
                the thorn that is heavier than lead – 
 
                        if it’s all you can do to keep on trudging – 
 
                                there is still somewhere deep within you 
 
                                        a beast shouting that the earth 
 
                                                is exactly what it wanted …" 
 
These words are for those of us who have felt the pain 
 
        of not being exactly who we wanted to be; 
 
                and for those who have had to hoist the heavier burdens of life: 
 
                        illness, disappointment, loss; 
 
                                and also for those of us whose personal struggles 
 
                                        are mundane but no less tragic or impenetrable. 
 
For any of us, the thorn can become heavier than lead at any time.       
 
When it does, 
 
        there is still the beast deep within, 
 
                still shouting, 
 
                        still living in the spirit  
 
                                of what is light, natural and free. 
 
That is where prayer can lead, 
 
        if we let it take us there. 
 
  
 
Prayer is primitive and fundamental. 
 
It is the naked recognition of who we are  
 
        and what we want. 
 
Prayer is speaking the truth to ourselves, 
 
        not always an easy thing to do. 
 
We express ourselves in our most vulnerable state. 
 
Perhaps that is why people have sent their prayers to heaven: 
 
        far away, 
 
                safely out of reach. 
 
  
 
But what we need is what can reach us: 
 
        to sense the spirit within, 
 
                and know the truth of ourselves. 
 
The truth is what can reach us. 
 
Prayer is letting it find us. 
 
Once we know the truth, 
 
        we are free to change and grow 
 
                and find what we are seeking in life. 
 
  
 
We religious liberals are skeptical about prayer 
 
        because we reject the materialism  
 
                of asking for something we want, 
 
                        and we lack the belief in a supernatural agent to provide it. 
 
But asking for what we need, 
 
        whether that is the strength to change and grow, 
 
                or the courage to face our fears, 
 
                        or the willingness to move closer to others – 
 
                                asking is the first step 
 
                                        towards finding what we need, 
 
                                                and becoming the agents  
 
                                                        of our own true selves. 
 
In this sense, we pray to the spirit within us 
 
        that helps us to move in the direction we desire. 
 
As Bishop Spong says, 
 
        "There is no magic here!" 
 
There may even be no God here, 
 
        just the human yearning to live honestly 
 
                and to be true to oneself. 
 
  
 
I still pray to God,  
 
        because if I need to pray badly enough, 
 
                I don't have time to define and qualify what I mean. 
 
But if I were to define and qualify what I mean, 
 
        I would say that God is the spirit at the center of life 
 
                in which I place my trust and my vulnerability. 
 
Something like that. 
 
Bishop Spong's definition works well too: 
 
        "God is the presence in whom my being comes alive." 
 
  
 
But you don't need God to pray. 
 
You only need your true self, 
 
        and a willingness to open your true self 
 
                to your deepest yearnings, hopes and fears. 
 
Whatever you have is enough. 
 
I also want to tell you my one other belief about prayer. 
 
When my prayers are answered, 
 
        I give thanks. 
 
I try never to forget to give thanks. 
 
It may be some imaginary transaction going on in my head, 
 
        but it does not feel complete to me 
 
                until I have acknowledged my gratitude 
 
                        for whatever I have received. 
 
Perhaps I'm relieved  
 
        that whatever crisis provoked the prayer is over. 
 
Or I realize one day 
 
        that something has changed in me 
 
                and that I have grown in some way I really needed to do. 
 
Or I think about my life and feel grateful. 
 
I give thanks. 
 
And then I move on,  
 
        no longer as heavy as lead, 
 
                more in touch with my true self, 
 
                        knowing, at least for that moment, 
 
                                that something holy goes with me too 
 
                                        and is never too far away.       
 

 

Sources:
"The Spirit of the Maasai Man," by Laura Berkeley (New York: Barefoot Books, 2000)
"Why Christianity Must Change or Die," by John Shelby Spong (New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 1998).

 

Copyright 2000, Rev. Judith E. Meyer
This text is for personal use only, and may not be copied
or distributed without the permission of the author.



KINGAFAP is a term coined by Brian Wren: King, Almighty Father, and Protector. Back up to essaySee more on Wren and language. Kingafap will also give some results in Google.





Men's Business
Mud Map Theology Studies Conversations Thinking Where I Live Sermons Mark Politics Words Computing Jan's Links Fundamentalism Sexuality in the Uniting Church  Replies, Responses, Debate
Latest Pages     © Jan Thomas


The Web One Man's Web