One Man's Web > Politics and Ethics > Australia and the refugees >  Unlawful!!!??
Posted  6/6/2004

Children's release from detention "unlawful"

I've posted this article pretty much "as is" from CathNews.  What more can anyone say?

Five asylum seeker children whom Centacare South Australia has supervised living in a suburban Adelaide home for several months could be forced back into a detention centre after Australia's highest court ruled their release into the community was unlawful.

All seven High Court judges found that the Family Court did not have the power to order the release of the children, aged seven to 15, from the Baxter detention centre in South Australia last August.

Upholding the Federal Government's appeal, the court said the Family Court had no jurisdiction to make orders concerning the welfare of children held in immigration detention.

The scheme of mandatory detention of unlawful non-citizens, including children, was valid under Australia's Constitution and the court could not invoke international law to override those provisions, it said.

Refugee advocates had hoped the case could pave the way for the release of the 137 children in detention centres in Australia and Nauru.

Immigration Department figures show 62 children are in immigration detention centres in Australia, including Christmas Island, and 75 at Nauru. Of those in Australia, 40 have been held for more than six months.

 Note that The Human Rights and Equal Opportunities Commission says this detention is a breach of children's human rights. (Jan) CathNews continues:

Centacare director Dale West, which has responsibility for the children, said they had been going to school, were playing sport and had made friends.

"I really hope we can negotiate to find a solution which doesn't involve them going to back to Baxter," Mr West said.

The two boys, three girls and their mother joined their asylum seeker father in Australia in 2001, claiming to have fled the Taliban in Afghanistan.

But the Refugee Review Tribunal held the family were Pakistani nationals. The boys escaped from Woomera detention centre in 2002 and on their return the Family Court proceedings began.

The five children live with a carer and regularly visit their mother and baby brother, who are in a nearby high-security motel. Their father is in Baxter detention centre.

Children's release from detention unlawful (West Australian 30/4/04)

High Court reverses children in detention decision (ABC TV Lateline 29/4/04)
High Court overturns kids out of detention decision (ABC Radio PM 29/4/04)
Children may go back to detention (The Age 30/4/04)
High Court overturns children in detention decision (ABC West Coast SA 29/4/04)
Centacare Adelaide

30 Apr 2004

Maybe, I'm naive. Maybe issues of jurisdiction between what court has the power where, are much more important than the compassion shown to children. Who cares if they are suicidal? What matters it if their lives are screwed up forever.  Perhaps it is more important to keep Pakistani fathers who maybe didn't tell the whole truth out of Australia. Maybe the government needs the power to act and keep control of the country with out do- gooder judges getting in the way. 

Or maybe what really is important is the life of children. So what if their father lied (if he did)?  They are here now. We have treated them, and their parents, like dogs.  Do we not owe them the chance of a decent life and some healing, some reparation, instead of leaving them to live from day to day not knowing if they will be shoved on a plane to God knows where.

I know which sort of country I would rather live in.

One Man's Web > Politics and Ethics